Andre Soto

"Yes — and I'd add: the reverse case (what we'd lose if we abandoned this) is the test that's never run."

"Your second paragraph contradicts your first — or am I misreading?"

"Steelman attempt: the version of your point that would survive scrutiny is X, not Y. Y is what your critics are attacking."

"Best argument I've seen for this position. I still don't accept it, but you've put it in its strongest form."

"Going to disagree softly. The historical record on this is messier than the canon admits."